By Jim Spencer
SpencerSpeaks.com

October 18, 2007

It’s been roughly 2 ½ months since the Telluride Town Council in southwest Colorado famously called for the impeachment of both the President and Vice President of the United States. That publicity stunt was as impotent as impeachment proposals introduced in 2006 in the state legislatures of Illinois and California.

The only would-be Democratic presidential candidate to say much, if anything, about impeachment is Ohio Congressman Dennis Kucinich. He tried to introduce articles of impeachment against Vice President Dick Cheney. The move went nowhere.

Americans have the right to express their outrage with George W. Bush and his henchmen. But don’t look for impeachment at this point in his administration.

Look instead for smart politicians to run away from divisive pipe dreams.

The Republicans were never going to win an impeachment vote against Bill Clinton. The Democrats can’t win one against Dubya. It’s not only futile; it’s self-destructive.

The caterwauling from the left wing of the Democratic Party notwithstanding, the path to greater domination in Congress and re-taking the White House doesn’t pass through hearings to remove the president from office.

So while impeachment votes like the one in Telluride may get you in the national news for a day or two, they don’t do much months and years down the road.

“The MoveOn.org crowd is frothing at the mouth with so much hatred of Bush that they’re missing a chance to say why Democrats should be elected,” said Ken Bickers, chairman of the political science department at the University of Colorado at Boulder.

This isn’t a call for censorship. Feel free to post “Impeach Bush” signs in public parks and private yards. Feel free to stick them on your car bumper or to hoist them while standing on street corners as Denver’s Green Party has done.

Just don’t plan to make a difference.

Colorado State University political analyst John Straayer laid it out perfectly.

“Standing on a street corner opposing or supporting something, that’s American politics,” Straayer said. “But no one should expect to generate an impeachment movement.”

It comes down to a choice between expressing outrage or getting results.

As Straayer asked, not so rhetorically: “Where do want to put your time and energy?”

Ugly and corrupt as you might think it is, the administration of Bush the Second is almost over. Logistically, Congress lacks the time for impeachment hearings. Practically, it may lack the high crimes and misdemeanors by the president. Politically, it certainly lacks the will.

That’s not a cop out so much as a reality check.

“Serious Democrats are looking at recent history,” said Bickers. “When the Republican right went after Clinton, it worked to the Democrats’ favor. If the Democrats go after Bush, that would be what he needs to rally his base.”

It could also alienate independents the Democrats need to tighten their grip on Congress and win the White House.

Calls for impeachment won’t help Kucinich win the Democratic presidential nomination. They just mark him as more of a wing nut.

For a counterpart in the GOP who’ll say just about anything, think Tom “Torture the Terrorists” Tancredo.

Speaking of water-boarding without borders, that is a real campaign issue. It is, said Straayer, one of a series of blunders by Bush and his boys that can engage folks who recoil at the prospect of impeachment.

“I don’t know that talking about impeachment hurts or helps,” Straayer explained. “More than anything it’s a manifestation of a build up of frustration around the administration’s handling of the Iraq War, Katrina and now SCHIP (the State Children’s Health Insurance Plan, which Bush vetoed and the House couldn’t override Thursday).”

Tax cuts for the rich are set to expire. The federal deficit is so high you can see Pluto with the naked eye. The government may be looking at your cell phone records. Beyond SCHIP, the whole American health care system is screwed up. And of course, there is Iraq, ever Iraq, costing thousands of American lives and half a trillion American dollars.

“For the well-being of the country,” said Straayer, people need to focus on all of that, not impeachment.

“The reality is that it’s not going to happen,” he said. “The reality is there are better things to spend your time on.”

Copyright 2007 by Jim Spencer. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.